Livelihood protection allowance rate (the population pair)  Average 8.4
Worst 1;

Hokkaido 18.5
Fukuoka 15.9
Osaka 15.6
Kouchi 15.6
Kyoto 14.3
Worst 2;

Okinawa 13.5
Aomori 12.2
Nagasaki 11.5
Tokyo 11.3
Kagoshima 11.1
   Best 1;

Toyama 1.8
Gifu 2.2
Fukui 2.3
Nagano 2.4
Yamanashi 2.8
Best 2;

Shizuoka 3.0
Ishikawa 3.2
Gunma 3.3
Yamagata 3.5
Ibaraki 3.8